© 2026
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

WMP&I's Matt Szafranski on ongoing legal spat between MGM Springfield, city

FILE - MGM Springfield
James Paleologopoulos
/
WAMC
FILE - MGM Springfield

For the past few months, a legal battle has been playing out between the city of Springfield and the company overseeing the MGM Springfield casino.

Last month, the city went public with a legal complaint aimed at getting the casino’s operators to make good on parts of their “host community agreement.”

At the same time, new reporting detailed how MGM had been looking to sell the downtown casino – and that, according to MGM, the city has been stalling since before that announcement.

WAMC’s Pioneer Valley Bureau Chief James Paleologopoulos spoke with Western Mass Politics & Insight Managing Editor Matt Szafranski about the latest developments.


Paleologopoulos: Talk to me about how we got here. I recall, a year ago, a Massachusetts Gaming Commission meeting that was held at Springfield City Hall.

In it, we actually heard Mayor Domenic Sarno spending some time honing in on MGM Springfield - particularly, how a property at 101 State Street had been languishing, despite the casino agreeing to help rehab it, Sarno claimed.

Looking at the timeline now, it kind of looks like there was more going on there ... and there was. Back in September of this year, the Springfield Republican newspaper reported MGM had told the city it planned to sell its casino at least two years ago. In March 2026, they apparently found a buyer. All of this less than 10 years after the casino opened.

Szafranski: [Years ago], MGM had originally tried to get one of the eastern [provisional casino] licenses, and when that didn't work out, they turned their gaze west.

It was in the middle of a much broader expansion of the industry beyond their traditional fortresses in Las Vegas and other well-known gaming cities.

I think that over the course of time, and perhaps before MGM Springfield opened - and definitely after the pandemic - they began to rethink the idea of these larger facilities, but also not really have an interest in running smaller facilities.

And so, the idea of them selling has always been a whisper going on for years. I don't think it was always their intention to do so, but perhaps it was inevitable that they would, given the way that the market and the industry was changing again, especially after the pandemic.

But even some of the signs were there before.

So fast-forward to 2024. You may recall, and some of your listeners may recall, that there was a rather strange fight erupting between... I believe it was some of the table employees and MGM over unionization, which seemed very strange, given the fact that they had essentially not fought an earlier unionization drive at MGM.

The principal concern or thought was is that they were preparing MGM Springfield for a sale.

Well, it turns out that that's exactly what was going on because in filings, in what are called "arbitration demands" - what is done to initiate an arbitration that you have agreed to enter into to resolve a dispute with a counterparty - it's clear that things were beginning to move in 2024, and, certainly, having another bargaining unit would be a complication to reaching an agreement with a potential buyer.

Not necessarily a deal-breaker, but just could potentially lower the value to the buyer, and therefore lower the price for that MGM would get.

Paleologopoulos: And we do have a buyer, or at least one that was named two months ago [by the Springfield Republican] - Clairvest, a private equity company based in Toronto that's purchased MGM properties before and has a bit of a gaming portfolio at this point.

This kind of casts a different light on what I initially reported a month ago. It was a little piece, and I wasn't really privy to the city and MGM's talks before the September announcement.

Now, you've poured over the court documents from MGM's side of things and - speaking of arbitration - as of last week, a judge ruled that yes, this is heading toward private arbitration, which, as you've said, the city was looking to avoid.

With its lawsuit, the city was really looking to grill MGM on only hiring about half of the 3,000 personnel it initially sought to hire, [how] the facility has significantly less games than what the city was hoping for and, of course, 101 State Street wasn't rehabbed.

Though, there were recent reports that some kind of work was happening there.

Szafranski: The lawsuit itself was ostensibly about trying to go after some of those commitments, but the most important part of it was to try to stay this arbitration, because the city was claiming that the issue with 101 State Street that's explicitly not covered by arbitration.

MGM said "no, actually, because you decided to make this about the the sale, you've now made 101 State Street fair game for arbitration," and I suspect that that really freaked out City Hall because ... there's a very real risk they could lose control of this issue, and it seems - I wouldn't say it's impossible - but it's very unlikely they would be able to get a judge afterward to say, "Oh no, no, no! This arbitrator was completely wrong," because that's a very hard thing to do in law, to say the arbitration law doesn't apply - both before and after the fact.

The only thing the courts can do is to determine whether or not something is arbitrable, but that is limited too.

What the city, then, was trying to do, is they wanted to get a preliminary injunction to stay the arbitration, and in effect, what they were hoping for... I don't know if this was intended to be just a delaying tactic or if they were hoping to just get all of the issues resolved in court under one fell swoop.

Whatever happens with the arbitration, in theory, this lawsuit could continue to go on. In fact, because Blue Tarp [reDevelopment LLC] would just be transferred interest from MGM to Clairvest, in theory, the case could go on no matter who owns Blue Tarp.

Now, whether or not Clairvest might be like "Well, you know what? We're going to take [a] different tack - we're just going to make all these things whole in the host community agreement" - that's fine.

But obviously the city doesn't want that ... they think of the sale as leverage to get many of these other things - and I suspect the most important of these is the refurbishment, renovation, rehabilitation - whatever of 101 State Street, above all else, and and I think MGM realized that as well because reading the ultimate decision from the judge - the city could have had a lot more shoved into arbitration than it ultimately ended up having with MGM's demand.

Paleologopoulos: For context, Blue Tarp reDevelopment, LLC, technically operates the casino, while MGM Resorts is the parent company.

So, while all this is going on, we've seen a figure emerge in terms of what kind of damages Springfield could be forced to pay under certain circumstances.

A number that's been thrown around has been $500 million. We should be clear, a lot of this comes by way of the Springfield Republican's Jim Kinney, who has also diligently followed this case.

I know we're talking potential damages, but where does this number come from?

Szafranski: My guess is that it's probably somewhere in the neighborhood of what Clairvest is willing to pay [MGM].

Maybe not exactly, but they might be thinking that this is the cost of everything included with the sale, the cost of paying for lawyers to get things through the Gaming Commission and for negotiations and all that other stuff - and then the final price on it.

Now, practically speaking, I would be very surprised if an arbitrator - especially given how not particularly clear what it is that can be arbitrated vis-a-vis the transfer rights - I would find it very unlikely that an arbitrator would grant a multi-million dollar judgment, in essence, against the city, and that a court would uphold it.

That price is simply unrealistic and I think it would be very hard to sustain that.

And to be honest, MGM would probably not... I don't think the public relations aspect of it would look really good either. You know, [headlines like] "MGM bankrupts a city in New England." I mean, that would not play well back home in Las Vegas, in terms of people coming to their other properties.

That being said, I don't think the danger is zero, and even if it was like a few million dollars, that would still be a blow to the city and that would have to be borne by taxpayers or the state would have to help out, which would not make anybody happy.

Especially given the fact that it seems pretty clear - and it's important to emphasize that this is only MGM's side of it, the city has not put forward any evidence to contest what MGM has put forward - but it does seem very clear that the city may have been jerking MGM around, and not negotiating with them in good faith.

That could totally be wrong, and if that evidence exists and they put it before the arbitrator, I would expect that MGM would not necessarily get away with it as easily.

The city is not as disadvantaged in arbitration the way individuals are. Arbitration, most oftentimes, comes up as ... that fine print you don't read at the bottom of a [user agreement] for software or something, that says you agree to have this arbitrated in, you know, Silicon Valley on this day of the week and only under these certain conditions.

That isn't as much of an issue for Springfield. Springfield is a large enough body and it could certainly function in an arbitration. What they don't want is the loss of the leverage, the loss of control - they would prefer it to be public if there's going to be any litigation on this.

[This is all] to say nothing of the fact that nobody knows how this all interacts with the Gaming Commission process - the Gaming Commission would still have to approve any sale, any transfer - and that just creates a whole bunch of smoke that the city would rather not have to try to squint [through], to figure out its place and what it can get out of the whole situation.

Paleologopoulos: Matt, thank you so much for your time.

Szafranski: Thank you!

—

This story originally aired on Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2026.

WAMC notes that, in a recent op-ed, MGM Springfield President Louis Theros said $25 million had been committed to redeveloping 101 State Street.

He added that repair work to the building's roof and facade was underway.