Penn Museum Apologizes For 'Unethical Possession Of Human Remains' | WAMC

Penn Museum Apologizes For 'Unethical Possession Of Human Remains'

Apr 27, 2021
Originally published on April 28, 2021 3:41 am

Dozens of human skulls of Black people — some hundreds of years old — will be returned to their communities of origin for reburial, according to a commitment by the University of Pennsylvania's Museum of Archeology and Anthropology.

Last week, the Penn Museum issued both an apology for possessing the skulls in its historic Morton Collection, and outlined a plan to repatriate them.

"The Penn Museum and the University of Pennsylvania apologize for the unethical possession of human remains in the Morton Collection," wrote Christopher Woods, who became the new director of Penn Museum on April 1. "It is time for these individuals to be returned to their ancestral communities, wherever possible, as a step toward atonement and repair for the racist and colonial practices that were integral to the formation of these collections."

The Morton Cranial Collection includes nearly 900 human skulls obtained during the early 19th century by a Philadelphia scientist named Dr. Samuel Morton, who sought to determine racial differences. He measured their cranial cavities — the part where the brain sits — by filling the skulls with peppercorns, then emptied them out and measured the volume of the seeds.

Morton believed a larger cranial cavity indicated better intelligence. He used his data to lend scientific support to white supremacy, which he wrote about in his 1839 book, Crania Americana. Morton is sometimes referred to as the "Father of Scientific Racism."

Today, brain size is not considered proof of higher intelligence, and Morton's racist conclusions are not accepted by the scientific community. At issue now is the way he acquired the skulls: mostly from grave robbers. About a dozen are believed to have been dug out of a potter's field in Philadelphia where poor African Americans had been buried. Over 50 more were exhumed from a graveyard of African slaves in Cuba.

"It was gathered unethically. None of it was with consent. These folks couldn't consent, given their position in society," said Abdul-Aliy Muhammad, a Philadelphia activist.

When Muhammad learned of the Morton skulls two years ago, at an event presented by the Penn & Slavery Project, he felt it in his own bones.

"My body was hot. My heart was pounding. I was really enraged, really angry at knowing this information," he says.

Muhammad is among those demanding that the skulls be repatriated from the museum, which has held them since 1966.

As one of the largest collections of historic human skulls in America, the Morton Collection has been used by modern researchers to study more benign things like the effects of diet and disease on the anatomy.

The origins of the collection, which was expanded after Morton's death in 1851, has never been secret: during a public lecture in 2011, Penn Museum Keeper of Physical Anthropology Janet Monge called Morton a "flaming racist." Many of the skulls were kept in a glass case inside a classroom until last summer, when, under pressure from activists, the museum removed them and began seriously considering how to address the problem they represented.

"It was the direct result of the killing of George Floyd, the rise of Black Lives Matter," said Woods. "This is what brought this issue to the forefront."

This month, Woods released a plan to form a new committee that will assess and determine how each skull will be repatriated: to Cuba, to communities in Philadelphia, and — if appropriate — to Africa. The committee will include people from Penn's offices of Social Equity and Community, Government and Community Affairs, the University Chaplain and General Counsel.

Some activists who have been rallying for the repatriation of the skulls welcome the move, but think it does not go far enough. "Penn admits that this is harmful. That's useful as an apology. But I think the apology has to be more robust," says Muhammad. "There's a commitment to a conversation with community, but we want a commitment to have the community on this committee, and not just Penn people. Right now, as it stands, [it] is only Penn staff."

Muhammad is also demanding that all scientific data collective from the skulls — collected both by Morton and any researcher thereafter — not be used, as the data was not collected by consent of its subjects.

One of the challenges of sending these skulls back where they belong is determining where exactly that is. Dr. Morton keep very little information about the people to whom these skulls belonged, other than their race.

"The pseudo-scientific research that he conducted was to justify white supremacist views of race," Woods says. "That was the one element of this that he was interested in. So those individuals are identified by race."

These were not just not consensually acquired, they were in many cases violently acquired: graves robbed, scavenged from battlefields, taken from gallows across the world. In a collection with that kind of history, it's necessary to really forefront the wishes of the descendant community with regard to what's to be done with these remains. - Paul Wolff Mitchell, fellow of the Penn Medicine and the Afterlives of Slavery Project

The process by which the remains will be repatriated will be modeled after the federal Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA).

However, unlike Native American remains, which are often associated with a known tribe, these skulls are essentially cut off from their own history. Take the example of a skull from an African slave in Cuba — the rest of the skeleton is still buried in Cuba, but while alive that person had been stolen from Africa, his native land. So where does the skull go?

The repatriation process will involve a combination of professional research and consultations with relevant communities to determine the best way to lay the bones to rest with dignity.

"These were not just not consensually acquired, they were in many cases violently acquired: graves robbed, scavenged from battlefields, taken from gallows across the world," says Paul Wolff Mitchell, a PhD anthropology candidate and a fellow of the Penn Medicine and the Afterlives of Slavery Project. "In a collection with that kind of history, it's necessary to really forefront the wishes of the descendant community with regard to what's to be done with these remains."

Copyright 2021 WHYY. To see more, visit WHYY.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Dr. Samuel Morton collected skulls, more than 900 of them. He was a scientist in Philadelphia back in the early 1800s. Morton claimed his studies of the skulls made the case for white supremacy. He's now considered the father of scientific racism, and his work is no longer accepted. But his collection of skulls remains at the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology. From member station WHYY, Peter Crimmins reports the Penn Museum is trying to return them to where they belong.

PETER CRIMMINS, BYLINE: Dr. Samuel Morton was measuring the cranial cavity of skulls, the part where the brain sits, by filling them with peppercorns and then taking the seeds out and measuring their volume. He believed a larger cranial cavity indicated greater intelligence and wrote in his 1839 book "Crania Americana" that white people were superior to other races.

Today brain size is not considered proof of higher intelligence, and Morton's racist conclusions are not accepted by the scientific community. At issue is the way Morton acquired the skulls, mostly from grave robbers. Paul Wolff Mitchell, an anthropology doctoral candidate at Penn, said about a dozen are believed to have been dug out of a potter's field in Philadelphia where poor African Americans were buried. Over 50 more were exhumed from a graveyard of African slaves in Cuba.

PAUL WOLFF MITCHELL: These were not just - not consensually acquired. They were, in many cases, violently acquired, grave-robbed, scavenged from battlefields, taken from gallows across the world.

CRIMMINS: When activist Abdul-Aliy Muhammad learned about the collection two years ago, he felt it in his own bones.

ABDUL-ALIY MUHAMMAD: My body was hot. My heart was pounding. I was really enraged, really angry at knowing this information.

CRIMMINS: Both Muhammad and Mitchell are demanding the skulls be repatriated from the Penn Museum, which has held them since the 1960s. As one of the largest collections of historic human skulls in America, the Morton collection has been used by modern researchers to study more benign things, like the effects of diet and disease on the anatomy. Until last year, the collection had been on display in an anthropology classroom. Museum director Christopher Woods said that after the skulls were removed from view last summer, a committee was formed to address the problem of the Morton collection.

CHRISTOPHER WOODS: It was instigated by everything that was happening in the country in 2020 - the killing of George Floyd, the rise of Black Lives Matter.

CRIMMINS: Last week, after eight months of internal discussion, the Penn Museum publicly apologized for the unethical possession of the Morton skulls and outlined a plan to repatriate them, using as a model the federal Native American Graves and Repatriation Act. But unlike Native American remains, which are often associated with a known tribe, these skulls are cut off from their own history. Take the example of a skull from an African slave in Cuba. The rest of the skeleton is still buried in Cuba. But while that person was alive, he had been stolen from Africa, so where does the skull go?

WOODS: Each case is a individual case - right? - that has its own context, its own complications. But, you know, it's just so important that this work be done as carefully as possible and that we really understand what the descendant communities want.

CRIMMINS: Woods is forming a new committee at the Penn Museum which will identify and consult with communities who can lay claim to a skull. Some activists say the plan does not go far enough, demanding community members are not just consulted but actually sit on the committee and have a direct voice on the way to lay these bones to rest with dignity.

For NPR News, I'm Peter Crimmins.

(SOUNDBITE OF EMANCIPATOR'S "NEVERGREEN") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.